The popular organizations which came into existence during the Russian Revolution
were called “Councils of Workmen's and Soldiers' Deputies.” These
bodies were supposed to hold things together under the provisional
government until the election of a constituent assembly could take
place; in a sense, they were vigilance committees designed to guard
against counter-revolution. The Petrograd Soviet
of 4,000 members was the most important of these, on account of its
position in the capital and its influence over the garrison.[1]
At the beginning of the Revolution, these soviets were under control of the Socialist Revolutionary Party, and even the Mensheviks had a larger share of the elected representatives than the Bolsheviks. But as World War I
continued and the Russians met defeat after defeat, and the provisional
government proved inadequate at establishing industrial peace, the
Bolsheviks began to grow in support. By degrees, the Bolsheviks
dominated with a leadership which demanded "all power to the soviets."[1]
The Bolsheviks promised the workers a government run by workers'
councils to overthrow the bourgeoisie's main government body - the
Provisional Government. In October 1917, the provisional government was
overthrown, giving all power to the Soviets. John Reed, an American
eyewitness to the October Revolution, wrote, "Until February 1918
anybody could vote for delegates to the Soviets." Even had the
bourgeoisie organised and demanded representation in the Soviets, they
would have been given it. For example, during the regime of the
Provisional Government there was bourgeois representation in the
Petrograd Soviet – a delegate of the Union of Professional Men which
comprised doctors, lawyers, teachers, etc.[2] Similarly, Leon Trotsky wrote in Terrorism and Communism
(1920) that "In Petrograd, in November 1917, we also elected a Commune
(Town Council) on the basis of the most democratic voting, without
limitations for the bourgeoisie. These elections, being boycotted by the
bourgeoisie parties, gave us a crushing majority. The democratically
elected Council voluntarily submitted to the Petrograd Soviet... the
Soviet Government placed no obstacle in the way of the bourgeois
parties; and if the Cadets, the SRs and the Mensheviks, who had their
press which was openly calling for the overthrow of the Soviet
Government, boycotted the elections, it was only because at that time
they still hoped soon to make an end of us with the help of armed
force... If the Petrograd bourgeoisie had not boycotted the municipal
elections, its representatives would have entered the Petrograd Council.
They would have remained there up to the first Social Revolutionary and
Cadet rising, after which...they would probably have been arrested if
they did not leave the Council in good time, as at a certain moment did
the bourgeois members of the Paris Commune."[3]
Lenin wrote that the Soviets were originally politically open and inclusive entities, writing in The Proletarian Revolution and the Renegade Kautsky
(1918) that, "the disenfranchisement of the bourgeoisie is not a
necessary and indispensable feature of the dictatorship of the
proletariat." And in Russia, the Bolsheviks, who long before October put
forward the slogan of proletarian dictatorship, did not say anything in
advance about disenfranchising the exploiters. This aspect of the
dictatorship did not make its appearance “according to the plan" of any
particular party; it emerged of itself in the course of the
struggle...even when the Mensheviks (who compromised with the
bourgeoisie) still ruled the Soviets, the bourgeoisie cut themselves off
from the Soviets of their own accord, boycotted them, put themselves up
in opposition to them and intrigued against them. The Soviets arose
without any constitution and existed without one for more than a year
(from the spring of 1917 to the summer of 1918). The fury of the
bourgeoisie against this independent and omnipotent (because it was
all—embracing) organisation of the oppressed; the fight, the
unscrupulous, self—seeking and sordid fight, the bourgeoisie waged
against the Soviets; and, lastly, the overt participation of the
bourgeoisie (from the Cadets to the Right Socialist—Revolutionaries,
from Milyukov to Kerensky) in the Kornilov mutiny — all this paved the
way for the formal exclusion of the bourgeoisie from the Soviets."[4]
The Bolsheviks and their allies came out with a program called
"soviet government." The soviet system was described as "a higher type
of state” and “a higher form of democracy" which would "arouse the
masses of the exploited toilers to the task of making new history."
Furthermore, it offered "to the oppressed toiling masses the opportunity
to participate actively in the free construction of a new society".
According to Lenin, the author of these quotations, soviet rule "is
nothing else than the organized form of the dictatorship of the
proletariat." A code of rules governing elections to the soviets was
framed in March 1918, but the following classes were disqualified to
vote: "Those who employ others for profit; those who live on incomes not
derived from their own work — interest on capital, industrial
enterprises or landed property; private business men, agents, middlemen;
monks and priests of all denominations; ex-employees of the old police
services and members of the Romanov dynasty; lunatics and criminals."[1]
With village and factory soviets as a base, there arose a vast
pyramid of district, cantonal, county and regional soviets, each with
its executive soviet. Over and above these stood the "All-Russian Soviet Congress," which appointed an "All-Russian Central Executive Committee" of not more than 200 members, which in turn chooses the "Soviet of People's Commissaries"
— the Ministry. Beginning with a minimum of three and maximum of 50
members for smaller communities, the maximum for town soviets was fixed
at 1,000 members. The soviet system was seen as an alternative to
parliamentary systems for administering republican governments.[1]
No comments:
Post a Comment